Showing posts with label more cats? calm down sean. Show all posts
Showing posts with label more cats? calm down sean. Show all posts

Sunday, April 26, 2009

After a Word From These Sponsors...

Here are some links on advertising and reasoning.
Now for some news stuff.
Finally, here's a recent Saturday Night Live skit on the distortions of political ads:
Lies in News?

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Stubborn = Intellectually Dishonest

Here's a little rant on a favorite topic of mine: intellectual honesty. A simple goal of this class is to get us all to recognize what counts as good evidence and what counts as bad evidence for a claim. I think we're getting better at that. But it's not clear that we're caring about the difference once we figure it out.

Getting us to care is the real goal of this class. We should care about good evidence. We should care about it because it's what gets us closer to the truth. When we judge an argument to be overall good, THE POWER OF LOGIC COMPELS US to believe the conclusion. If we like an arg, but still stubbornly disagree with its conclusion, we are just being irrational.

This means we should be open-minded. We should be willing to let new evidence change our current beliefs. We should be open to the possibility that we might be wrong. This is how Todd Glass puts it:


Here are the first two paragraphs of a great article I read in the Fall on this:

Last week, I jokingly asked a health club acquaintance whether he would change his mind about his choice for president if presented with sufficient facts that contradicted his present beliefs. He responded with utter confidence. "Absolutely not," he said. "No new facts will change my mind because I know that these facts are correct."

I was floored. In his brief rebuttal, he blindly demonstrated overconfidence in his own ideas and the inability to consider how new facts might alter a presently cherished opinion. Worse, he seemed unaware of how irrational his response might appear to others. It's clear, I thought, that carefully constructed arguments and presentation of irrefutable evidence will not change this man's mind.

Ironically, having extreme confidence in oneself is often a sign of ignorance. Remember, in many cases, such stubborn certainty is unwarranted.

Certainty Is a Sign of Ignorance

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

I'll Rationalize... Later

Links-a-plenty on superstition and rationalization:
And some links on procrastination:
[Placeholder for Funny AltText]

Monday, April 13, 2009

Wished Pots Never Boil

Here are a few links on the psychological impediments we're discussing recently:
Does Wishful Thinking Work Yet?

Thursday, April 2, 2009

Homework #2

Homework #2 is due at the beginning of class on Tuesday, April 7th. The assignment is to answer problems 1-15 in Exercise 5-1 on pages 110-111 of our textbook. Just tell me what fallacy each argument commits. Don't worry about explaining why the argument commits the fallacy. Also, these arguments don't just commit fallacies from chapter 5. Some commit fallacies from older chapters.

(If you read this, write "Why is anything anything?" at the bottom of your homework to get some extra credit on the assignment.)

Just You Wait, Henry Higgins, Just You Wait

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Fallacies, Fallacies, Everywhere

My best friend the inter-net has some nice examples of the fallacy of equivocation. Here are two good ones:

A feather is light.
What is light cannot be dark.
Therefore, a feather cannot be dark.

Margarine is better than nothing.
Nothing is better than butter.
Therefore, margarine is better than butter.
Also, speaking of non sequiturs, here's a cute cat picture:

Did. Not. See. That. Coming.

Wait, we weren't just speaking of non sequit--Oh. I see what you did there.

Clever.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Possible Paper Articles

Here are some links to good articles you could use for your paper on explaining and evaluating an article's argument:

Bad Stereotyping
race & gender = insufficient info


The Idle Life is Worth Living
in praise of laziness

In the Basement of the Ivory Tower
are some people just not meant for college?

The Financial Crisis Killed Libertarianism
if it wasn't dead to begin with

Consider the Lobster
David Foster Wallace ponders animal ethics

Who Would Make an Effective Teacher?
we're using the wrong predictors

Loyalty is Overrated
adaptability & autonomy matter more

FBI Profiling
it's a scam, like cold reading

Singer: How Much Should We Give?

just try to think up a more important topic

The Dark Art of Interrogation
Bowden says torture is necessary

Can Foreign Aid Work?
Kristof says it has problems, but we should use it

Against Free Speech
but it's free, so it must be good

You Don't Deserve Your Salary
no one does

What pro-lifers miss in the stem-cell debate
love embryos? then hate fertility clinics

Is Worrying About the Ethics of Your Diet Elitist?
since you asked, no

Is Selling Organs Repugnant?
freakonomicists for a free-market for organs

Should I Become a Professional Philosopher?
hell 2 da naw

Blackburn Defends Philosophy
it beats being employed

I Could Read All These

Thursday, February 12, 2009

35 + 101 = 217?

So, I was wrong. They used 217 dalmations to film the live-action remake of 101 Dalmations, not 35 or so like I made up in class. I'm fascinated at how fake facts can seep into my feeble mind like that. Fortunately, one of the lessons of our class is that I'm not alone.

Anyway, here are some more random fun facts: The only semi-reliable source I was able to find on the total population of dogs on Earth places the number at around 400 million. That book, however, doesn't explain how it arrived at that figure, and it does warn that the estimate could be off fairly significantly.

I found a map the top ten pet dog populations by country (although again there's no source on this map's estimates, so caveat emptor):

USA NUMBER 1 WOOOOOO
Also, some dogs do not bark. That's why, in the inductive argument we discussed in class, I was careful to conclude only that "Most dogs bark," not "All dogs bark."

Hey, this is too much focus on dogs for my taste.

That's More Like It

Monday, February 9, 2009

Cat Statements

What kind of statements are these?

Ninja

No Touching

Or Maybe Someone Farted

Apathy Is Underrated

Let us know in the comments.

Friday, February 6, 2009

Evaluating Deductive Args

Here are the answers to the handout on evaluating deductive arguments that we went over in class. Perhaps I should have titled the handout "So Many Bad Args!"

1) All kangaroos are marsupials.
All marsupials are mammals.
All kangaroos are mammals.
P1- true
P2- true
structure- valid
overall - sound
2) (from Stephen Colbert)
Bush was either a great prez or the greatest prez.
Bush wasn’t a great prez.
Bush was the greatest prez.
P1- questionable ("great" is subjective)
P2- questionable ("great" is subjective)
structure- valid (it's either A or B; it's not A; so it's B)
overall- unsound (bad premises)
3) Some people are funny.
Sean is a person.
Sean is funny.
P1- true (we might disagree over who specifically is funny, but nearly all of us would agree that someone is funny)
P2- true
structure- invalid (the 1st premise only says some are funny; Sean could be one of the unfunny people)
overall- unsound (bad structure)
4) All email forwards are annoying.
Some email forwards are false.
Some annoying things are false.
P1- questionable ("annoying" is subjective)
P2- true
structure- valid (the premises establish that some email forwards are both annoying and false; so some annoying things [those forwards] are false)
overall - unsound (bad first premise)
5) All bats are mammals.
All bats have wings.
All mammals have wings.
P1- true
P2- true (if interpreted to mean "All bats are the sorts of creatures who have wings.") or false (if interpreted to mean "Each and every living bat has wings," since some bats are born without wings)
structure
- invalid (we don't know anything about the relationship between mammals and winged creatures just from the fact that bats belong to each group)
overall- unsound (bad structure)
6) Some dads have beards.
All bearded people are mean.
Some dads are mean.
P1- true
P2- questionable ("mean" is subjective)
structure- valid (if all the people with beards were mean, then the dads with beards would be mean, so some dads would be mean)
overall- unsound (bad 2nd premise)
7) This class is boring.
All boring things are taught by Sean
This class is taught by Sean.
P1-questionable ("boring" is subjective)
P2- false (nearly everyone would agree that there are some boring things not associated with Sean)
structure- valid
overall- unsound (bad premises)
8) All students in here are mammals.
All humans are mammals.
All students in here are humans.
P1- true
P2- true
structure
- invalid (the premises only tell us that students and humans both belong to the mammals group; we don't know enough about the relationship between students and humans from this; for instance, what if a dog were a student in our class?)
overall- unsound (bad structure)

9) All hornets are wasps.
All wasps are insects.
All insects are scary.
All hornets are scary.
P1- true!
P2- true
P3- questionable ("scary" is subjective)
structure- valid
overall- unsound (bad 3rd premise)
10) All students in here are humans.
All humans are shorter than 10 feet tall.
All students in here are shorter than 10 feet tall.
P1- true
P2- true!
structure- valid (same structure as arg #1)
overall- sound
11) If Sean sings, then students cringe.
Sean is singing right now.
Students are cringing right now.
P1- questionable (since you haven't heard me sing, you don't know whether it's true or false)
P2- false
structure- valid
overall- unsound (bad premises)
12) If Sean sings, then students cringe.
Sean isn't singing right now.
Students aren't cringing right now.
P1- questionable (again, you don't know)
P2- true
structure- invalid
(from premise 1, we only know what happens when Sean is singing, not when he isn't singing; students could cringe for a different reason)
overall- unsound (bad 1st premise and structure)
13) If Sean sings, then students cringe.
Students aren't cringing right now.
Sean isn't singing right now.
P1- questionable (again, you don't know)
P2- true
structure- valid
overall- unsound (bad 1st premise)
14) If Sean sings, then students cringe.
Students are cringing right now.
Sean is singing right now.
P1- questionable (again, you don't know)
P2- false
structure- invalid
(from premise 1, we only know that Sean singing is one way to guarantee that students cringe; just because they're cringing doesn't mean Sean's the one who caused it; again, students could cringe for a different reason)
overall- unsound (bad premises and structure)

Try Again... FOREVAR!
(More on Sisyphus)

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Understanding Args

Here are the answers to the handout on understanding arguments that was assigned as optional extra credit.

1. (P1) Fairdale has the best team.
(C) Fairdale will win the championship

2. (P1) The housing market is depressed.
(P2) Interest rates are low.
(C) It's a good time to buy a home.

3. (P1) China is guilty of extreme human rights abuses.
(P2) China refuses to implement democratic reforms.
(C) The U.S. should refuse to deal with the present Chinese government.

4. (P1) The results of the Persian Gulf War were obviously successful for the U.S. military.
(C) The U. S. military is both capable and competent.

5. (P1) Scientific discoveries are continually debunking religious myths.
(P2) Science provides the only hope for solving the many problems faced by humankind.
(C) Science provides a more accurate view of human life than does religion.

6. (P1) Freedom of speech and expressions are essential to a democratic form of government.
(P2) As soon as we allow some censorship, it won't be long before censorship will be used to silence the opinions critical of the government.
(P3) Once we allow some censorship, we will have no more freedom than the Germans did under Hitler.
(C) We must resist all effort to allow the government to censor entertainment.

7. (P1) I'm very good at my job.
(C) I deserve a raise.

8. (P1) Jesse is one year old.
(P2) Most one-year-olds can walk.
(C) Jesse can walk.

9. (P1) The revocation of the 55 mph speed limit has resulted in an increased number of auto fatalities.
(C) we must alleviate this problem with stricter speed limit enforcement.

10. (P1) The last person we hired from Bayview Tech turned out to be a bad employee.
(C) I'm not willing to hire anybody else from that school again.

11. (P1) Maebe didn't show up for work today.
(P2) Maebe has never missed work unless she was sick.
(C) Maebe is probably sick today.

12. (P1) The United States, as the most powerful nation in the world, has a moral obligation to give assistance to people who are subjected to inhumane treatment.
(P2) The ethnic Albanians were being persecuted in Kosovo.
(C) It was proper for the U.S. to become involved in the air campaign against Kosovo.

----------------
Hat tip: I took some of the examples (with some revisions) from Beth Rosdatter's website , and some (with some revisions) from Jon Young's website .

The LOLCat Dolls

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Email Subscription

So why does this course have a blog? Well, why is anything anything?

A blog (short for “web log”) is a website that works like a journal – users write posts that are sorted by date based on when they were written. You can find important course information (like assignments, due dates, reading schedules, etc.) on the blog. I’ll also be updating the blog throughout the semester, posting interesting items related to the stuff we’re currently discussing in class. I used a blog for this course last semester, and it seemed helpful. Hopefully it can benefit our course, too.

Since I’ll be updating the blog a lot throughout the semester, you should check it frequently. There are, however, some convenient ways to do this without simply going to the blog each day. The best way to do this is by getting an email subscription, so any new blog post I write automatically gets emailed to you. (You can also subscribe to the rss feed, if you know what that means.) To get an email subscription:

1. Go to http://rowanlogic.blogspot.com.

2. At the main page, enter your email address at the top of the right column (under “EMAIL SUBSCRIPTION: Enter your Email”) and click the "Subscribe me!" button.

3. This will take you to a new page. Follow the directions under #2, where it says “To help stop spam, please type the text here that you see in the image below. Visually impaired or blind users should contact support by email.” Once you type the text, click the "Subscribe me!" button again.

4. You'll then get an email regarding the blog subscription. (Check your spam folder if you haven’t received an email after a day.) You have to confirm your registration. Do so by clicking on the "Click here to activate your account" link in the email you receive.

5. This will bring you to a page that says "Your subscription is confirmed!" Now you're subscribed.

If you are unsure whether you've subscribed, ask me (609-980-8367; landis@rowan.edu). I can check who's subscribed and who hasn't.

The internet is only good for logic blogs and cat pictures

Course Details

Logic and Everyday Reasoning
Rowan University
Philosophy 09110, Section 1
Spring 2009
Tuesdays and Thursdays
8:00 a.m. – 9:15 a.m. in Wilson Hall, Room 207

Instructor: Sean Landis
Email: landis@rowan.edu
Phone: 609-980-8367
Course Website: http://rowanlogic.blogspot.com

Required Text
Logic and Contemporary Rhetoric, 10th edition (Howard Kahane & Nancy Cavender)

About the Course
We are presented with arguments for all sorts of conclusions all the time, on topics as serious as abortion or the death penalty and as trivial as who the Phillies best player is or whether Letterman is funnier than Leno. How can we tell good arguments from bad ones?

This course focuses on understanding and evaluating arguments. We’ll first learn how to identify the components and structures of arguments. We’ll then learn how to pick apart the bad reasoning found in some arguments by going over logical fallacies, which are the different ways an argument can go wrong. We’ll also discuss psychological impediments that can throw us off. These are the ways most people naturally are led to reason incorrectly.

Armed with these evaluative tools, we’ll then explore our arguments for what we believe, and revise or strengthen them based on proper reasoning. The course’s main goal is to develop a respect for arguments and reasoning as an important, if not the most important, tool toward figuring out the truth.

Straw Person is Less Sexist

Grades
93.3-100% = A
90-93.2% = A-
86.7-89.9% = B+
83.3-86.6% = B
80-83.2% = B-
76.7-79.9% = C+
73.3-76.6% = C
70-73.2% = C-
66.7-69.9% = D+
63.3-66.6% = D
60-63.2% = D-
below 60% = F

Midterm: 15%
Final: 25%
Quizzes (2): 7.5% each (15% total)
Oral Report: 15%
Short Paper: 5%
Group Projects (3): 3% each (9% total)
Other Homework (3): 4% each (12% total)
Attendance/Participation: 4%

Exams: The midterm tests everything covered during the first half of the course, and will last the full period (75 minutes). The final exam is cumulative: it tests everything covered throughout the whole course. The final will last 75 minutes during Finals Week.

Quizzes: Quizzes aren’t cumulative. Quiz #1 tests everything covered during the first 4 weeks of class, and quiz #2 tests everything covered after the midterm (weeks 7 through 9). Quizzes will last 20 to 25 minutes, and be held at the beginning of class on the scheduled day.

Oral Report: This will be a group project presented in front of the class at the end of the semester. Each group of 3-5 students will research a topic and present a 10- to 15-minute oral presentation on it to the rest of the class.

Short Paper: There will be one short paper (250-500 words each) on understanding and evaluating an argument.

In-Class Group Projects: In addition to the group project and a lot of informal group work, there are three in-class group projects due at various times throughout the semester.

Other Homework: There will be three total homework assignments. Each one is due at the beginning of class the day they are due.

Attendance/Participation: Most of this will be based on your attendance. If you’re there every class, you’ll get full credit for your attendance grade. In addition, informal group work can impact your grade.

Extra Credit: There will be some optional extra credit assigned throughout the semester.

Classroom Policies
Academic Integrity: Cheating and plagiarism (using someone else’s words or ideas without giving credit to the source) will not be tolerated in the class. Students found guilty of either will definitely fail the exam or assignment—and possibly the entire class.

Excused Absenses: Make-up exams, quizzes, in-class projects, and oral reports will only be rescheduled for any excused absences (excused absences include religious observance, official college business, and illness or injury – with a doctor’s note). An unexcused absence on the day of any assignment or test will result in a zero on that assignment or test.

Ask Me About My Bunny

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Course Schedule

January 21—23
Tuesday: Introduction to class (no reading)
Thursday: Critical Thinking Intro (no reading)

January 28—30
Tuesday: Evaluating Args (1.1-1.5)
Thursday; Arguments: Deductive (2.1-2.3) (group work)

February 3—5
Tuesday: Fancier Args & Statements (2.4-2.5)
Thursday: Arguments: Inductive (2.6-2.8)
Homework #1 due

February 10—12
Tuesday: Arguments: Abductive (1.6-1.11) (group work)
Thursday: Fallacies (3.1-3.3)
Quiz #1

February 17—19
Tuesday: Fallacies (3.4-3.7)
Thursday: Fallacies (3.8)
Group Project #1 (in class)

February 24—26
Tuesday: Fallacies (4.1-4.4)
Thursday: Fallacies (4.5-4.7) (group work)

March 3—5
Tuesday: Fallacies (5.1-5.4)
Homework #2 due
Thursday: Fallacies (5.5-5.8)

March 10—12
Tuesday: Fallacies & Review for Midterm (5.9)
Group Project #2 (in class)
Thursday: MIDTERM

March 17—19
SPRING BREAK! (no class) (woo?)
carpe diem, lazy bones

March 24—26
Tuesday: Psychological Impediments (6.1-6.3)
Paper #1 due
Thursday: Psychological Impediments (6.4-6.6)

March 31—April 2
Tuesday: Psychological Impediments (6.7-6.9)
Thursday: Cognitive Biases (handout)
Group Project #3 (in class)

April 7—9
Tuesday: Intellectual Honesty: Charity (3.3, 3.7, 4.5)
Thursday: Intellectual Honesty: Ignorance (handout)

April 14—16
Tuesday: Writing Essays (9.1-9.4)
Quiz #2
Thursday: Writing Essays & Evaluating Ads (10.1-10.5)

April 21—23
Tuesday: Evaluating Ads & News (11.1-11.4)
Homework #3 due
Thursday: Evaluating News (11.5-11.8) (group work: presentation prep)

April 28—30
Tuesday: group presentations
Thursday: group presentations & review for Final Exam

Week of May 5—9
FINAL EXAM
(Time and date to be announced)

Reason Is No Panacea